Climbing Grades: Comparison Chart and Rating Systems Overview

A GUIDE TO ROCK CLIMBING GRADES
Photo: Maria Ly

This guide serves as an introduction to the main grading systems used in the United States, including the V-Scale for bouldering and the Yosemite Decimal System for roped climbing. It also provides an overview of the the National Climbing Classification System (NCCS) and aid climbing grading systems. See our international Climbing Grade Comparison Chart to see how grades in the US convert to those abroad.


Bouldering grades: V-Scale

climbing grade comparison chartEstablished by John Vermin Sherman in the bouldering mecca of Hueco Tanks, the V-Scale ranges in difficulty from V0 (easiest) to V16.

Occasionally, a plus (i.e. V2+) will designate a bouldering problem being on the harder side of the the grade, while a minus indicates a climb being on the easier, or “softer,” side of the grade. Also, a VB rating may be used to designate a problem easier than V0 and intended for beginners.

 

Roped climbing grades: Yosemite Decimal System (YDS)

America’s grading system for roped climbs is the Yosemite Decimal System, which is divided into five classes. Roughly outlined, these are as follows:

  • Class 1: walking
  • Class 2: hiking; occasional use of hands
  • Class 3: scrambling with the use of hands
  • Class 4: basic climbing at elevation; a fall could be fatal and ropes are often used
  • Class 5: technical rock climbing on steep terrain and requiring ropes, harnesses, belay equipment, etc.

For the purposes of modern rock climbing, all grades occur within Class 5 and range in difficulty from 5.0-5.15c. When established by the Sierra Club in the 1930s, however, Class 5 grades were intended to range from only 5.0-5.9. Anything above 5.9 was previously regarded as impossible.

 

The evolution of the Yosemite Decimal System of grades

Unable to contain breakthroughs of the last half-century, grades have steadily been pushed upward. Additionally, letters a, b, c, and d have been implemented above the 5.9 rating to further distinguish individual grade increments. An a is indicative of the easier side of the numbered grading level, followed by b, c, and d as the hardest. Note that the difference between 5.11a and 5.11b is theoretically the same difference in difficulty between 5.7 and 5.8.

Although grades are implemented as a system for consistency, they can vary greatly between indoors, outdoors, and across different climbing destinations. Locations such as Joshua Tree are notoriously hard or “stiff” in the gradings, whereas modern sport climbing crags may be softer.

Joshua Tree

Related: What’s in a Grade? How to Approach Climbing Difficulty

 

Rock climbing protection ratings

In addition to the number and letter grade above, outdoor roped climbs may also include a protection rating. This rating is a combination of the danger of the climb, along with the degree of spacing between protection/bolts (how “run-out” the climb is). These ratings correlate with the movies:

  • PG: occasional run-out sections
  • PG-13: these climbs tend to be fairly run-out, and the leader should be very competent at the grade
  • R: designated for very run-out or dangerous climbs where a fall could be fatal
  • X: these climbs are truly “no-fall” climbs; there exists little to no quality protection

A look at The Bachar Yerian 5.11c R/X one of the most famous run-out and “no fall” climbs:

 

National Climbing Classification System (USA)

Not to be confused with the class system outlined under the Yosemite Decimal System, the NCCS grading scale measures what climbers often refer to as the “commitment Grade.” This system essentially categorizes the time investment an average climbing team must commit in order to successfully complete a route. These are especially useful in places like Yosemite, where routes can vary from quick multi-pitch outings to multi-day big wall climbs.

  • Class I and II: 1/2 a day or less for the technical (5th class) portion of a route
  • Class III: Most of a day of roped climbing
  • Class IV: A full day of technical climbing
  • Class V: Typically requires spending a night on the route, or done fast and free in a day
  • Class VI: Two or more days of hard climbing
  • Class VII: Remote walls climbed in alpine style
Yosemite Valley climbing grades
Photo: Maria Ly

Related: Climbing Destination Guide: Yosemite Valley, California

 

Aid climbing grade rating systems

Aid climbing, in contrast to free climbing, involves pulling or standing on fixed or placed protection to ascend a section of rock. This style of climbing—most often used during big wall ascents—has several scales for grading, including the Original Grading System, the Clean Climbing Rating System, and the New Wave Rating System. For each, the system measures the quality/dependability of gear placements and the level of danger in the event of a fall. Many consider aid climbing grades to be especially arbitrary, as skills, equipment, height, and other elements can greatly effect the difficulty of a route.

When the letter “A” precedes a number grade, this suggests that the route requires or features placements that require the use of a hammer, such as copperheads or pitons. The letter “C,” by contrast, means that the route can be climbed clean; instead relying on passively placed protection, such as cams, nuts, or hooks.

Petzl Ascension Ascender

Black Diamond Camalot C4

Black Diamond Etrier

Petzl Ascension AscenderBuy Now Black Diamond Camalot C4Buy Now Black Diamond EtrierBuy Now

A simplified outline of the New Wave / Clean Climbing aid rating systems:

  • A0 or “French Free”: A free climb with an occasional aid move that does not require specialized aid climbing gear, such as etriers. This often involves pulling on bolts.
  • A1, C1-C2 (beginner): Considered beginner aid, most of the climbing is straight forward with secure placements. Some aid climbing gear, like hooks, cam hooks, even a couple pitons, (which are often fixed on beginner routes) may be necessary.
  • A2-A3, C2-C3 (intermediate): Moderate aid climbing with some tricky gear placements. There is no long fall potential, but some aid-specific gear is likely required.
  • A3+-A4, C3-C4 (advanced): Involves hard aid climbing with many tenuous placements in a row. Long or dangerous fall potential may exist. Gear may be secure, but will not hold falls.
  • A4-A5,C4-C5 (expert): Consecutive tenuous and body-weight only placements that could result in a fall of 20-meters or more. These require extreme technical expertise and mental strength. A single pitch could take many hours to lead.

What terrifyingly hard aid climbing looks like:


Want to learn more about climbing and the lingo? Check out our Climbing Glossary.

More from Natalie Siddique

3 Friction Hitches Every Climber Should Know — How to Use and Tie an Auto-Block, Prusik, and Klemheist

Use this guide as a general overview. Remember, learning about rock climbing...
Read More